Rachel Derenthal 5/28/19 Rachel Derenthal 5/28/19

Extending Family Lines in the 1800s: Using Alternative Records to Build Evidence

It all begins with an idea.

When conducting genealogical research in the 1800s, it becomes essential to shift your focus away from the modern records we rely on today—namely civil birth, marriage, and death certificates. These government-created vital records simply did not exist in the forms we recognize until much later. As a result, researchers working in this period must rely heavily on alternative records to reconstruct family lines and develop direct or indirect evidence of kinship.

Church records can occasionally provide information on marriages, baptisms, and burials, but they are often limited in detail, especially when it comes to proving specific family relationships. Therefore, understanding how to locate, interpret, and correlate alternative records becomes a crucial skill for anyone researching in the 19th century.

This article outlines the major alternative record groups that can help you successfully extend a family line when traditional sources fall short.

1. Probate Records

Probate records are among the richest sources of genealogical information for the 1800s. They include:

Wills
Intestate proceedings (when a person dies without a will)
Letters of administration
Administrators’ accounts
Guardianship records
Property distributions and estate sales

These documents often contain direct evidence of kinship. A will may name a spouse, children, and sometimes siblings or other relatives. Intestate packets, while sometimes less detailed, can still identify heirs and their relationships to the deceased. Guardianship records, in particular, can be invaluable for identifying minor children, confirming parentage, or showing extended familial ties.

2. Land Records

Land records are another foundational resource for the 1800s, especially when probate records are missing, incomplete, or never created. Even individuals with small estates typically left at least one trace in the land books.

Why land records matter:

Deeds often list the heirs or legatees of a deceased person when property is being divided or sold.
Signatures of multiple heirs can help confirm relationships.
Sometimes deeds include a note stating that an heir is living “out of state,” providing clues for migration patterns.
Land descriptions and acreage can help differentiate between individuals of the same name in a community.

Land records are particularly powerful when tracing ancestors who moved from one location to another. For example, if the last known record of an ancestor is in Illinois, but you suspect they came from Pennsylvania, broad searches in Pennsylvania land records for the surname can help identify a likely home region.

A future article will explore specialized tools and strategies for these broader, exploratory searches—searches that feel less like finding a needle in a haystack and more like feeling your way through a dimly lit tunnel. While they may seem time-consuming, there are ways to make this process more efficient and worthwhile.

3. Tax Records

Tax records are an underused but incredibly helpful resource for the 1800s.

They can help you:

Identify potential sons or other relatives of a known individual
Distinguish between multiple men with the same name in a community
Track land ownership over time
Identify when a person appears or disappears from a county (often signaling a move, death, or coming of age)
Determine townships or districts in which a family lived

Tax lists often include acreage, number of livestock, household counts, and property locations. When combined with land and probate records, tax lists help ensure you are researching the correct individual and not conflating multiple people with identical names.

4. Church Records

As mentioned earlier, church records are often the only direct source of vital information during the 1800s. However, they come with challenges:

Families changed religious affiliations more often than we might assume—especially within the many Protestant denominations.
Immigrant families may have belonged to specific ethnic congregations (e.g., German Lutheran, Italian Catholic).
Churches may no longer exist, or their records may be scattered.

Still, if you have a general idea of your family’s religious background—whether German Lutheran, Methodist, Catholic, or another tradition—these records can be invaluable.

To narrow searches, use clues from:

Estimated marriage dates (based on ages of children or census entries)
Migration patterns
Known baptismal sponsors or witnesses
Nearby congregations active during your ancestor’s lifetime

Church records rarely spell out relationships directly, but when pieced together with other evidence, they can strongly support kinship hypotheses.

Additional Alternative Records

There are many other, less commonly used record groups that become essential when working through tough brick-wall cases. These will be explored in a future post, but they include:

Court minutes
Military records
Pension files
Poorhouse and almshouse registers
Cemetery surveys
Local histories and biographical sketches
School, occupational, or apprenticeship records
Newspapers and legal notices

These sources may not always contain direct evidence, but when correlated properly, they can create a compelling body of indirect evidence supporting your genealogical conclusions.

Final Thoughts

Researching in the 1800s requires creativity, persistence, and a firm grasp of how alternative records can interact to form a reliable case for lineage. By mastering probate, land, tax, and church records—and knowing when to expand into more obscure resources—you can extend your family lines even when traditional vital records are unavailable.

More posts are coming soon that will walk you through deeper strategies, specialized tools, and case studies that illuminate how these records work together to solve genealogical puzzles.

Rachel Derenthal 5/28/19 Rachel Derenthal 5/28/19

Blog Post Title Two

It all begins with an idea.

It all begins with an idea. Maybe you want to launch a business. Maybe you want to turn a hobby into something more. Or maybe you have a creative project to share with the world. Whatever it is, the way you tell your story online can make all the difference.

Don’t worry about sounding professional. Sound like you. There are over 1.5 billion websites out there, but your story is what’s going to separate this one from the rest. If you read the words back and don’t hear your own voice in your head, that’s a good sign you still have more work to do.

Be clear, be confident and don’t overthink it. The beauty of your story is that it’s going to continue to evolve and your site can evolve with it. Your goal should be to make it feel right for right now. Later will take care of itself. It always does.